The alleged "insider" claimed that Kieran Gibbs is an ex of India's and she attended his birthday party over the weekend.
Meanwhile, another alleged source who claims to have close ties to India also rubbished the allegations, telling the Mail Online "She attended his birthday party with her family".
At the time, he was questioned on whether they'd said the L-word to one another, he confessed: 'I can not say love.
Twitter obviously went into meltdown over the rumours. Tweets included: "How ON EARTH did Ovie get cheated on, he's the literal definition of perfect" and "Who tf in their right mind would cheat on Ovie".
India's reps however have denied these claims.
2019 Love Island finalist India Reynolds is reportedly "shocked and hurt" by the recent cheating allegations against her.
"There is no truth in this whatsoever and Ovie and India are still very much together and happy", a representative for the model told The Sun.
Following desires from Love Island fans to have Ovie hook up with his good friend and the show's eventual victor Amber Gill, Twitter users spied an opportunity. Anton and Belle broke up last week and Harley and Chris broke up three weeks ago, just two weeks after becoming exclusive.
India was a late arrival to the Love Island villa in July before swiftly falling for Ovie and later continuing their romance in the outside world.